Clarion-Ledger reports on silica defense verdict
Today's Clarion-Ledger contains an article on the defense verdict last week in a silica trial in Claiborne County. Here is the story. I originally mentioned the verdict last week. The article confirms that Fred Krutz with Foreman Perry led the defense team. The plaintiff was 73-year old Eugene Westrope of Hazlehurst. The defendants were Clemco (air-powered blast equipment), Precision Packaging (concrete producer) and Lone Star Industries Inc. (cement manufacturer). Judge Lamar Pickard was the trial judge.
The plaintiff asked for $4.5 million in damages. The jury returned a defense verdict in a 9-3 vote. In state court in Mississippi at least nine jurors must agree on the verdict. In the article, Krutz largely credited the win to the defendants ability to screen potential jurors who were involved or had family members involved in similar litigation. While I do not doubt the significance of the defendants' ability to assure a level playing field, they still had to try a good case to get the defense verdict once the jury was in the box.
