Mississippi Litigation Review & Commentary

Mississippi Litigation Review & Commentary

Comments on the Latest Developments in Mississippi Civil Litigation

For Mississippi native son and attorney Philip Thomas, blogging about law, politics and topical issues in the state extends a conversation he’s been... More

Category Archives: Mississippi Supreme Court

Subscribe to Mississippi Supreme Court RSS Feed

Updated Mississippi Supreme Court Scoreboard for 2013

Posted in Appellate Decisions From Jury Verdicts, Mississippi Supreme Court
Unless some decisions of verdicts have slipped through the cracks, here is the Mississippi Supreme Court’s record for ruling on verdicts so far in 2013: Decisions on Verdicts: 2 Plaintiff Verdicts Upheld: 1 (reversing court of appeals) Amount of Verdict Upheld: $500,000 Plaintiff Verdicts Reversed: 1 Amount of Verdict Reversed: $1 million My Take: Is … Continue Reading

Miss. Supreme Court’s Reversal of $1 Million Jury Verdict in Medical Malpractice Case is Example of Why State Court Judges Need to Alter System for Formulating Jury Instructions

Posted in Appellate Decisions From Jury Verdicts, Improving the Jury System, Mississippi Supreme Court
As discussed at TBA last week, on Thursday the Mississippi Supreme Court reversed and remanded a 2011 jury verdict of $1 million in a Hinds County case. Plaintiff alleged medical malpractice against Dr. Charles Laney. Here is the Court’s opinion in Laney v. Vance. The facts of the case were not important for purposes of the Court’s opinion. … Continue Reading

Miss. Supreme Court Issues “Whack” Decision on Punitive Damages

Posted in Mississippi Supreme Court
I borrowed the description of the Mississippi Supreme Court’s ruling in Coleman & Coleman Enterprises, Inc. v. Waller Funeral Home from a comment to Anderson’s post on the decision. It’s an apt description. The Court’s opinion made my head hurt.   From Anderson’s post: Punitive damages of $25,000 were awarded, but in a posttrial motion for … Continue Reading

A.P. Reports 5th Circuit Ruling in Sears v. Learmonth Will be Next Year

Posted in 5th Circuit Court of Appeals, Mississippi Supreme Court
An A.P. article on Tuesday stated that the 5th Circuit’s ruling on the constitutionality of Mississippi’s non-economic damages caps will not be made until 2013. The article reports that briefing will not be complete until December 3.  Oral argument has not been scheduled. Attorneys for the parties are uncertain about whether there will be oral argument: … Continue Reading

Thoughts on the Northern District Supreme Court Race

Posted in Mississippi Supreme Court, Politics in Mississippi
Patsy Brumfield filed a good article about the Northern District Supreme Court election. The article explains how Republican support for Josiah Coleman in the supposed non-partisan race translated to a big win. Long time readers of this blog know that I am a supporter of an appointed judiciary in Mississippi. The case for appointed judges … Continue Reading

Justice Randolph Fails to Save a Whale–Wins Re-election to Mississippi Supreme Court Anyway

Posted in Mississippi Supreme Court, Politics in Mississippi
Southern District voters re-elected Justice Michael Randolph to the Miss. Supreme Court yesterday, despite attacks by challenger Tal Braddock that Randolph has not saved any whales: “He’s an excellent justice, period. His opinions are well-written and he’s qualified … his worth ethic is outstanding. “Dag gum, this guy’s done everything but save the whales.” Hypothetical … Continue Reading

5th Circuit Moving Forward with Deciding Caps in Sears v. Learmonth

Posted in 5th Circuit Court of Appeals, Mississippi Supreme Court
The Mississippi Business Journal Reports that the 5th Circuit Court of Appeals is asking for more briefs in the Sears v. Learmonth case. This is the case where the Mississippi Supreme Court refused to decide the constitutionality of the state’s non-economic damages on a certified question from the 5th Circuit.  The 5th Circuit’s October 5, … Continue Reading

Good Grief, Charlie Brown: Mississippi Supreme Court Rules that Negligent Conduct by Governmental Entity is a Policy Decision

Posted in Mississippi Supreme Court
On Thursday the Mississippi Supreme Court reversed the Court of Appeals and ruled that an airport authority’s negligence in placing stairs at the terminal is a discretionary policy decision. Here is the Court’s opinion in Pratt v. Gulfport-Biloxi Regional Airport Authority. The plaintiff in the case was attempting to board a plane when he slipped and … Continue Reading

Plaintiffs Rolls Yahtzee – Supreme Court Sinks Their Battleship

Posted in Appellate Decisions From Jury Verdicts, Mississippi Supreme Court
In 2010 the Ohazurike family–of obscure board game fame–obtained a $3.6 million judgment in a Hinds County Circuit Court case that should have been in county court. Here is my post on the verdict.   On Thursday the Mississippi Supreme Court sank the Ohazurike’s proverbial Battleship in a unanimous decision. What was the Court’s vote? I’ll give you … Continue Reading

Footnote 7 Revisited: Can Jurors Bring Evidence into the Deliberation Room?

Posted in Mississippi Supreme Court
Can jurors decide a case based not on evidence presented at trial, but instead on a jurors’ personal experience? Footnote 7 from the Mississippi Supreme Court’s non-decision in Sears v. Learmonth created significant teeth gnashing on  this question in the legal community—at least among lawyers who read the footnotes. Footnote 7 was the majority’s response to … Continue Reading

Friday Special: Breaking Down Miss. Supreme Court’s Horse Play Decision in Pictures

Posted in Mississippi Supreme Court
The Mississippi Supreme Court decided Ladnier v. Hester on Thursday. January 2, 2008. Here’s what happened. Diego: "Dudes, I’m hungry." Sparky: "Yea, old man Hester doesn’t feed us enough." Trigger: "Do you guys see what I see?" Diego: "Right on! Pasture run tonight at midnight." Sparky: "I don’t have a watch." Trigger: "Shut up, Sparky." Sparky: "No … Continue Reading

Miss. Supreme Court Reverses $1 Million Trip and Fall Verdict

Posted in Appellate Decisions From Jury Verdicts, Mississippi Supreme Court
On Thursday the Mississippi Supreme Court reversed and remanded a $1.07 million judgment in a 2010 Hinds County trip-and-fall trial. This was a verdict obtained by Jackson attorney Ashley Ogden on behalf of a man who fell and injured his hip in Bailey Lumber & Supply in Jackson.  Here is the Court’s opinion. The verdict was for … Continue Reading

Mississippi Supreme Court Reverses $1.5 Million Verdict in Lincoln County Commercial Litigation Case

Posted in Appellate Decisions From Jury Verdicts, Mississippi Supreme Court
In 2010 a Lincoln County jury rendered a $1.5 million verdict for Precision Welding against Denbury Resources. Here is my post on the verdict. On Thursday the Mississippi Supreme Court reversed and remanded the case for a new trial in a 6–3 decision. Here is the Court’s opinion. Justice Dickinson wrote the majority opinion. The … Continue Reading

Supreme Court Strikes Damages Caps

Posted in Mississippi Supreme Court, Tort Reform
On Tuesday the Supreme Court struck the state’s damages caps on non-economic damages. Not the Mississippi Supreme Court, obviously. It was the Missouri Supreme Court striking that state’s caps. John Day links the opinion on his blog. In Mississippi, the Sears v. Learmonth case on the issue has been pending for so long that it’s been months since I’ve … Continue Reading

Mississippi Supreme Court’s Reversal of $2.6 Million Judgement Shows Why State Courts Need Better System for Jury Instructions

Posted in Appellate Decisions From Jury Verdicts, Improving the Jury System, Mississippi Supreme Court
On Thursday the Mississippi Supreme Court reversed and remanded a $2.6 million judgment in Miss. Valley Silica Co. v. Eastman in a 6–3 decision. Here is the Court’s opinion. The Court’s decision stemmed from a 2010 silica trial in Warren County that resulted in a $7.6 million jury verdict. The trial court reduced the verdict … Continue Reading

Mississippi Supreme Court and Court of Appeals on Customary July Break

Posted in Mississippi Court of Appeals, Mississippi Supreme Court
Anderson notes on his blog that the Mississippi appellate courts are on their customary July break: Back in two weeks. Based on what I’ve been reading lately, they need the rest. This is a normal break for the Court and coincides with the Bar Convention, which I believe is next week. Typically, not much happens … Continue Reading

Mississippi Supreme Court Reverses and Renders Hinds County Premises Liability Verdict

Posted in Appellate Decisions From Jury Verdicts, Mississippi Supreme Court
On Thursday the Mississippi Supreme Court reversed and rendered a $2.5 million jury verdict against Kroger in 2009 based on the 2007 beating of a customer in a purse snatching incident. Here is the Court’s opinion in Knox v. Kroger. I wrote on the verdict in 2009 here and here. Justice Dickinson wrote the Court’s … Continue Reading

Miss. Supreme Court Reverses and Remands $15.2 Million Asbestos Drilling Mud Verdict

Posted in Appellate Decisions From Jury Verdicts, Mississippi Supreme Court
On Thursday a unanimous Mississippi Supreme Court reversed and remanded a 2010 Jones County jury verdict of $15.2 million in an asbestos drilling mud case. Here is the Court’s opinion in Phillips 66 Co. v. Lofton. I previously wrote about the verdict here and here. The big appeal issue was statute of limitations. I attended … Continue Reading

Pickering and Hood Both Claim Victory in A.G. Private Attorney Fee Dispute

Posted in Mississippi Supreme Court, Politics in Mississippi
The Clarion-Ledger reported Friday on Thursday’s Mississippi Supreme Court decision that legal fees paid to private attorneys hired by Attorney General Jim Hood are public funds. The Court reversed two Hinds County judges who ruled that the attorney fees could be paid straight to the private attorneys. Both the plaintiff in the case (State auditor Stacey Pickering) and … Continue Reading

Edward Sanders’ Bottom Line Keeping Scoreboard of Mississippi Appellate Decisions

Posted in Mississippi Court of Appeals, Mississippi Supreme Court
Every week I look forward to the email with Ed Sanders’ Bottom Line, which summarizes the week’s decision by the Miss. Supreme Court and Court of Appeals. It’s a great way to keep up with the latest decisions. If you don’t already subscribe, you  can sign up for email delivery of the Bottom Line at Davidson … Continue Reading