October 22, 2010

Report: $103 Million Verdict Against Baker & McKenzie Law Firm in Jones County Legal Malpractice Case

I just received a report of a $103 million compensatory damages verdict today in the Circuit Court of Jones County against a Texas law firm for legal malpractice. The law firm allegedly represented both sides of a transaction, disregarded the instructions of the plaintiff and caused the plaintiff (a millionaire) to lose almost everything.

Eric Tiebauer of Waynesboro reportedly represents the plaintiff. I will have more information as it becomes available.

10:00 p.m. Update: New info. on this massive verdict is being posted in the comments section. The style of the case was Evans v. Baker & McKenzie, which is one of the largest law firms in the world with over 3,000 lawyers. The largest group of lawyers appear to be in the Chicago office.

Michael J. Shemper of Hattiesburg and Laurence E. Best and Peter S. Koeppel of Best Koeppel, New Orleans, for Cross-Plaintiffs, Laredo Energy Holdings, LLC, and its subsidiaries, obtained $22.4 M of that verdict for their clients.

The newly released Mississippi Jury Verdict Reporter will report on the verdict and I will post more information as I get it.

6:00 p.m. Saturday update: The Baker & McKenzie lawyer who was the defendant in the case has been identified as Joel Held in the firm’s Dallas office. The firm’s web site states that Mr. Held is a 1964 graduate of the Boston University law school and lists the focus of his practice as:

Mr. Held regularly represents securities issuers and individuals and a variety of broker dealers in investigations, enforcement matters, regulatory issues, litigation and compliance matters. He also handles private litigation, particularly those involving securities class action defense and securities-related matters. Additionally, Mr. Held provides sound counsel on public offerings, private placements, mergers, acquisitions, leveraged buy-outs, reorganizations, other types of business combinations, formations and transactions, as well as joint ventures and partnerships.

Twitter
Facebook
Email
LinkedIn

Defense Verdict in Stealth Hinds County Medical Malpractice Trial

A Hinds County Circuit Court jury returned a defense verdict on Monday in a medical malpractice case tried before Judge Winston Kidd.

Here is the Complaint in the case filed by James McClure against Dr. Anthony Petro, Dr. Clark Ethridge and Mississippi Baptist Medical Center. The Complaint alleges that Dr. Petro perforated plaintiff’s bowel during a laparoscopic procedure and that defendants breached the standard of care in failing to diagnose and treat the perforated bowel.

Dr. Ethridge was quickly dismissed from the case via a summary judgment motion. I can’t tell from the docket when Baptist was dismissed, but it appears that Baptist was not at the trial.

The trial lasted one week and one day. The jury’s verdict was unanimous. Here is the jury’s hand-written verdict. I hear that the jury thought that the plaintiff’s case was very weak.

Salvador Bivalacqua of New Orleans represented the plaintiff. From the docket, it appears that Walter Johnson and Mildred Morris from Watkins & Eager represented the Dr. Petro. [correction: It was actually Jim Becker who tried the case for the defense with Walter Johnson. Becker is a legendary veteran of the Mississippi defense bar. Mildred Morris was not involved in the trial].

If anyone has more info. on this verdict I would be happy to report it. This is an example of a stealth defense verdict in a medical malpractice trial. This happens a lot. I heard about the verdict only because my wife is friends with the spouse of one of the jurors.

Twitter
Facebook
Email
LinkedIn